Discussion:
[urn] urn-registration-template-jaif-v2.txt
Jörg Walther
2017-12-11 06:51:44 UTC
Permalink
Dear all,

please find attached the request to register the urn:jaif for the Joint Automotive Industry Forum.

I kindly ask for conducting the registration process.

Thank you very much for your support.

Kind regards

Jörg


Jörg Walther
Odette International Ltd.
71 Great Peter Street
SW1P 2BN London
UK
Peter Saint-Andre
2018-04-13 03:02:09 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jörg Walther
Dear all,
Hi Jörg,

Thanks for your patience. I just realized that no one from the review
team has commented on your document (which you sent to the list just as
I was starting a new job).
Post by Jörg Walther
please find attached the request to register the urn:jaif for the Joint Automotive Industry Forum.
Your updated registration request looks good to me, and addresses the
feedback I provided last June.
Post by Jörg Walther
I kindly ask for conducting the registration process.
I will ping the other members of the review team to see if they have any
comments.

Peter
Svensson, Lars
2018-04-23 10:23:30 UTC
Permalink
Hello Jörg,
Post by Peter Saint-Andre
Hi Jörg,
Thanks for your patience. I just realized that no one from the review
team has commented on your document (which you sent to the list just as
I was starting a new job).
Post by Jörg Walther
please find attached the request to register the urn:jaif for the Joint Automotive
Industry Forum.
Your updated registration request looks good to me, and addresses the
feedback I provided last June.
Post by Jörg Walther
I kindly ask for conducting the registration process.
I will ping the other members of the review team to see if they have any
comments.
No technical comments from me, the registration seems OK.

One editorial nit:

"There are no known interopreability issues" should probably be " There are no known interoperability issues".

Best,

Lars
Dale R. Worley
2018-04-24 02:07:00 UTC
Permalink
I lost track of this submission as well.

It's quite well-done and straightforward. My only comments are a couple
of very minor editorial things.
The urn is not expected to become part of an IETF standard.
I think you want to change "urn" to "URN namespace" here.
The Namespace Specific String (NSS) of all URNs assigned by the
There are a couple of place where you say "the JAIF", whereas most are
simply "JAIF". You probably want to make these consistent.

Dale

Loading...